Question 70. SIRE and port State control: who carries them out, and what for?
Your Answer:
(Not answered)
Correct Answer:
D (one a commercial assessment by oil companies, the other statutory control by the port State)
💡 The two come from different places. The tanker inspection is a commercial assessment serving charterers, carried out against the industry questionnaire and guide from cargo working through life-saving, fire, passage planning and the people on board, scored and entered in a database the operators consult; it is not law enforcement, failing it breaks no law but can cost the ship her cargo, and findings go back to the charterer under contract. Control by the coastal State is enforcement under the conventions, examining certificates, equipment and practical operation, with deficiencies to be rectified by a date or the ship detained, the visit recorded in the regional system and bearing on how soon she is selected again. The same defect can appear in both reports, and each has to be answered on its own terms; a clean sheet from one does not excuse the other.