Question 72. A warship meets a merchant ship head on in territorial waters and the Second Officer argues that the Rules bind merchant ships only. Is that reading supportable under Rule 1?
Your Answer:
(Not answered)
Correct Answer:
A (wrong. Rule 1 applies to all vessels upon the high seas and in all waters connected therewith navigable by seagoing vessels; the special provisions for warships concern additional station lights, shapes and signals only, not exemption from the Rules)
💡 Rule 1(a) marks out two circles, waters and vessels: the high seas and all waters connected therewith navigable by seagoing vessels, and within them all vessels, whatever their type, nationality or tonnage. Paragraph (b) allows Governments to make special rules for additional station lights, shapes and whistle signals for ships of war, provided they cannot be mistaken, and special rules for roadsteads and harbours shall conform as closely as possible to the Rules. Reading warships as wholly exempt, confining the Rules to the high seas, or making length the dividing line are the usual misreadings.