Question 52. A bulker at full speed in fog hits an anchored ship who rang no bell. How do the faults fall?
Your Answer:
(Not answered)
Correct Answer:
C (the bulker without engines ready and without plotting the echo, the anchored ship showing no anchor light and ringing no bell, the fault lying on both)
💡 Both chains broke. The one under way: in restricted visibility the engines are to be ready for manoeuvre, the speed must suit the conditions, and the radar echo must be worked systematically so that a risk of collision is recognised in time - to run at full speed with no plotting leaves the judgement to the last minute, and the other ship silence does not discharge that duty. The one at anchor: the lights and sounds differ between being underway and being anchored, anchor lights are to be exhibited forward and, above the length stated in the rule, the required additional light as well, with bell and, in fog, gong to give the acoustic signal; not ringing left the approaching ship unable to fix her position or state. Liability follows what each fault contributed to the result, not a rule that the stationary or the moving one is to blame; here neither did the thing that would have avoided the collision.