Question 85. Two power-driven vessels are crossing and each believes the other is on her starboard side, for example through an error in judging courses or a misunderstanding. Under Rule 15 what is the correct treatment?
Your Answer:
(Not answered)
Correct Answer:
A (It is not possible for both to be correct in judging the other on their own starboard side; if one has judged wrongly she should act according to the actual position, being the stand-on vessel if the other is actually on her port side, judging the risk of collision and the bearing prudently under Rule 7 and acting appropriately under Rule 8)
💡 Under Rule 15 and the original geometry of a crossing situation it is not possible for both vessels to be correct in judging the other on their own starboard side, the directions being reciprocal. If one has judged wrongly, such as by misjudging the bearing, she should act according to the actual position, being the stand-on vessel if the other is actually on her port side, judging the risk of collision and the bearing prudently under Rule 7 and acting appropriately under Rule 8. It is therefore neither a case of both giving way or both standing on, nor one that can simply be dismissed as impossible.